In this, I feel that Deathly Hallows part 1 ultimately succeeds. Many things are different from the novel and there are even a few things that don't make any sense without an understanding of the story, but the spirit of Deathly Hallows is ever-present, clearly evident throughout the film, even when it stumbles in the plot.
The first half of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is about a lot of things. The idea that you can trust someone with all your heart only to be disappointed in them later, hopelessness, death, war, and friendship. These ideas are all rich and plentiful topics and the movie does an excellent job of examining them.
Another thing the movie does very well is create a sense of darkness from the very beginning. Half-Blood Prince very much set up a sense of foreboding, which is followed through in this film. The film starts off dark and stays that way for pretty much the entire time. The first ten minutes of the film establish the mood very well, but it would have lost its power if there hadn't been any follow through. But the follow through is near immediate. As soon as Harry and Hagrid break the clouds leaving Privet Drive, all hell breaks loose. This scene was intense in the book as well, but I think that this is something that can be done better in film than it can in prose. The chaos of the scene was almost overwhelming and there was no doubt in my mind that everyone was in real and terrible danger. This feeling of danger that is excellently created in this scene never lets up through the rest of the movie. Any time something breaks the tension: a joke for example, it is quickly counteracted by some new horrible development. When George makes his "I'm holy" joke, we barely get time to laugh before we learn that Mad-Eye is dead.
Of course, the film was not perfect. I would say that the plot was definitely the weakest element, with many plot points being ill defined or even bewilderingly absent to those who would not be familiar with the book. I am sure that the taboo on Voldemort's name must have been explained in a deleted scene, because Harry definitely uses You-Know-Who as opposed to Voldemort without explanation. The silver doe also seemed very weird and out of place. Of course, it wouldn't be explained until part 2 anyway, but the fact that Harry and Ron seem to forget all about it implies that we aren't supposed to care when it is actually a very critical point. Finally, the most bewildering aspect of the movie: the mirror shard. No explanation whatsoever is given for Harry having it and it seems so beautifully out of nowhere that you kind of have to laugh. It was confusing in the book too because we didn't know where the other half was, but at least we knew why Harry had it.
All in all though, I would say that Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1 was very successful telling of the story of the novel and the best Potter movie to date. I am eagerly awaiting the second half.
- It is really amazing how well they built up Dobby's character. Considering he was only in one other movie and was fairly annoying in it, this is a grand achievement. Over the course of only a few scenes, they made Dobby so lovable and entertaining that his death was extremely moving when it could have been a "who the hell cares" moment. Of course, in order to get that we had to lose out on a lot of Kreacher development, but I think it was an acceptable sacrifice considering.
- Bringing Hagrid and Harry down to the muggle street during the flight from Number 4 was inspired. It was visually interesting, chaotic, scary, and different than the status quo: everything that sequence needed to be. Voldemort destroying the power lines in anger was also powerful and terrifying.
- This note applies to the book as well, but I'd like to point it out here. It is great that Harry is not in control of the flying motorcycle at all. It puts him in such a helpless position, especially compared to if he had been on a broom where he would have felt some sense of comfort and control in the midst of all the chaos.
- Alan Rickman is a fantastic actor. Few other actors could say so much without moving a muscle.
- Also Luna. "Harry doesn't really want to talk to us. He's just too polite to say so." Fantastic and perfect line. I kind of have a huge crush on her.
- When the movie Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets came out, I was annoyed that they didn't have the voices change with Polyjuice potion. Now, many years later, I understand why. Can you imagine how confusing it would have been with The Seven Potters and The Ministry of Magic otherwise? And Rupert Grint's reading of the lines when he was Cattermole were absolutely brilliant.
- Also, shout out to the three actors that played Reg, Runcorn, and Mafalda. They were amazing.
- The animation for the tale of the three brothers was MIND-BLOWING. It was so terrific. Probably my favorite part of the movie.
- The only thing I wish they'd hit on a bit more was Harry's losing faith in Dumbledore. They did hit on it a bit, but I think it deserved a bit more time. Maybe in the next part.
- I love how many scenes in this film had no or little dialogue. I feel like filmmakers these days rely on dialogue a bit too much to tell a story and I am always happy when I see so much being conveyed visually. In particular, the scene with Hermione wiping her parent's memory, Ron becoming angry/jealous toward Harry and Hermione, and Harry dancing with Hermione were all beautifully and almost silently done.
- Finally, a shout out to my main man Dobby. Poor little guy. At least he died free and with friends. RIP Dobby.